Tuesday, February 21, 2012

IS THE PROPOSAL OF SENATOR ENRILE FOR THE PROSECUTION TO AMEND ARTICLE 3 A PLOY IN ORDER TO SEND BACK THE COMPLAINT BACK TO THE HOUSE??

I am not a lawyer but I have learned a few things after closely following the impeachment proceedings of President Erap, Ombudsman Gutierrez, Chief Justices Davide and now Corona.

The impeachment complaint against Corona has eight articles that are incorporated in one complaint. During the trial the prosecution may reduce the number of articles but they can not add to its number and amend it. If they want to add to its number of articles or to amend any of the articles, the whole complaint should be returned to the House. If they amend any of the articles, they in effect amend the whole complaint and so the amended complaint has to be returned to the House.

What if Congressman Tupas agreed this afternoon to amend article 3 by inserting the charge of bribery to the allegation and his having agreed to the amendment is already incorporated into the records? Of course Justice Cuevas of the defense will stand and argue that in as much as the complaint is already amended, it is necessary now to return it to the House! Senator Enrile will then rule approving the motion of the defense in as much as the record bears out that one article has been amended and so therefore the entire complaint is amended and give an order to refer back the complaint to the House, what can the defense do?

I was really wondering in today's trial why Senator Enrile had to say that he has been helping the prosecution in open court just to emphasize that he means well in proposing to the prosecution to amend article 3 by incorporating the charge of bribery against Chief Justice Corona.

I was also wondering why Senator Enrile single mindedly did not allow the witness who is an executive from PAL to be presented by the prosecution as he ruled that the witness is not relevant to article 3 unless a charge of bribery against the Chief Justice be included in article 3 which is tantamount to the amendment of the whole complaint which then necessitate its return to the House.

I was also wondering why not a single Senator requested for a motion for reconsideration or interposed objection to his earth shaking ruling as Presiding Chair as far as we simple folks are concerned by not allowing the main witness of the prosecution to be presented unless the article is amended and the charge of bribery be included.

I was also wondering why Senator Enrile was exceptionally harsh to the prosecution including some Congressmen while trying to propose to them to amend article 3 as if showing his displeasure when the prosecution refused his proposal.

I do not want to put ill motives on some of our esteemed leaders but I just want to share my apprehensions so that those of us who would like the truth to come out and for those of us who would like to see good governance in our country can prepare ourselves.

On February 28, a big rally said to be in support of the rule of law will take place. Out of my respect for many of them who are my friends and even relatives I will not mention their group, but they can give few millions of votes to national candidates and thousands to local candidates as their group always vote as one. All candidates ask for their support before elections and anyone who is supported is always a sure winner while one who is not supported should be extra strong in the polls in order to win without their support.

Our Senators are all politicians and if they will not be seeking re-elections, most probably a son, wife or a relative will be taking their place. They want to win of course in the forthcoming elections. If they go against the intention of the group that is mentioned above, they will lose the millions of votes the group can give for their candidacy or for their relatives. If they go against the desire of the President, they might also lose his support and the support of his supporters which they also do not want to happen.

How about a solomonic solution?

RETURN THE COMPLAINT BACK TO THE HOUSE AND LET THE HOUSE DELIBERATE THE AMENDMENT UNTIL THE CONGRESSMEN ACCORDING TO THEIR RULES AND EXISTING LAWS AGREE WHEN TO RESUBMIT IT TO THE SENATE FOR TRIAL!!

What will be the effects of this scenario if it is carried out?

One, the group that votes as one gets what they want which is what they call as rule of law.

Two, the Senators or their alternate will most probably be supported during the elections by the group having helped in carrying out the scenario.

Three, some Senators or aspiring to be Senators even if they are with the administration will now be considered possible beneficiaries of the group's block votes being cooperators also in the carrying out of the scenario.

How about PNoy,  will he not feel offended if this happens? Naturally Yes he will feel slighted but perhaps Not fully  if CJ Corona will voluntarily resign which most probably has already been pre arranged by the planners of the scenario. Besides the party mates of PNoy will tell him that they need the support of the block votes for their own candidacies and therefore will seek his passive cooperation.

How about the prosecution-Congressmen? Most probably they will not be forewarned but if they are, they must bring out their best acting abilities and ask for the support of the block as also players of carrying out the scenario.

Is this suspicion with basis? Or is this  just a fruit of my imagination after closely following the Impeachment Trial with the greatest hope that good governance will at last dawn on our beloved country where sense of accountability and transparency will be common traits among our public servants?

I can confidently say that this is possible!!!

Friends you can make your own conclusion or speculation.

But may I ask this question Friends and just give your answer to yourself.

Will you not feel short changed if after all these revelations about the SALN and bank accounts and condominium and the time spent by so many and the millions spent by our government and most of all our high expectations or feel betrayed if the respondent Chief Justice will not be judged after we have traveled this far?

How will you see our leaders who might participate in this zarzuela or charade?

Would you still see them  or their alternates fit to remain in office?

WE MUST ALWAYS EXERCISE OUR OFFICE AS THE BOSS!!!

1 Responses (Leave a Comment):

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.