Iglesia ni Cristo-led rally cheers up tearful Chief Justice
FROM WRITER MD14623
Perhaps it might help if one stops speaking of the impeachment trial as a trial to impeach the Chief Justice. The House has already impeached the Chief Justice when more than 85 congressmen signed the Articles of Impeachment.
Since the Chief Justice is considered impeached, the subject of impeachable offenses is a moot point. The 188 signatories of the articles of impeachment consider the offenses listed therein as impeachable offenses.
The only issue the Senator-Judges should resolve is whether the impeached should remain in office. This is the only issue. They are not called to impeach --- only the House can do that. They are not called to verify the articles of impeachment. The House is assumed to have done that. They are called to decide on only one issue and only one issue alone: Should the impeached remain in office?
This issue will be decided on political grounds by design. And this is only fair and just to the Filipino People.
One can see the framers of the Constitution took pains to control the damage to the impeached by limiting his loss only to the loss of a job and disqualification from serving in public office again.
The framers of the Constitution also took pains to pre-empt 'mob rule' by requiring a two-thirds majority vote from the Senate to convict. The impeached needs less than ten votes to keep his job.
While the work of the Prosecutors is deeply appreciated by a grateful nation, the burden of proof belongs to the impeached. It should be his to prove that he is worthy of the people's trust. It should not be the people's burden to prove a public servant is NOT worthy. For how in all that is intelligible and doable under the sun can anyone prove a negative?
The assumption that "a man is innocent until proven guilty" is necessary in a criminal court. However, in an impeachment case (where what is at stake is the people's sacred trust and not an individual's right to life, liberty or property) adhesion to this tenet is a perversion of justice. The impeached has no human rights here to protect. But the Filipino nation has the very Foundation of its Laws and Democratic Institutions to protect.
Just because the victims of the impeached's "betrayal of public trust" are a faceless mob, does not make this a victimless crime. An impeached occupying an exalted office should resign even if his "betrayal of public trust" is merely alleged but not proven. But the framers of the Constitution (in their infinite wisdom) also chose to grant the impeached a trial before the Senate as his right to due process (which I believe is more than a public servant suspected of betraying a sacred trust deserves.)
In short, the impeachment process as defined by the Philippine Constitution can only be viewed as a gift to the Chief Justice and other high ranking public servants. Public servants of lesser rank, where suspicion alone is grounds for dismissal, are not so lucky.
I hope this helps the Senator-judges properly weigh the cost to the impeached should they convict him against the greater cost to their constituents should they acquit him. They should ask themselves before they cast their votes what between the two choices will require courage on their part and make the courageous choice.
Since the Chief Justice is considered impeached, the subject of impeachable offenses is a moot point. The 188 signatories of the articles of impeachment consider the offenses listed therein as impeachable offenses.
The only issue the Senator-Judges should resolve is whether the impeached should remain in office. This is the only issue. They are not called to impeach --- only the House can do that. They are not called to verify the articles of impeachment. The House is assumed to have done that. They are called to decide on only one issue and only one issue alone: Should the impeached remain in office?
This issue will be decided on political grounds by design. And this is only fair and just to the Filipino People.
One can see the framers of the Constitution took pains to control the damage to the impeached by limiting his loss only to the loss of a job and disqualification from serving in public office again.
The framers of the Constitution also took pains to pre-empt 'mob rule' by requiring a two-thirds majority vote from the Senate to convict. The impeached needs less than ten votes to keep his job.
While the work of the Prosecutors is deeply appreciated by a grateful nation, the burden of proof belongs to the impeached. It should be his to prove that he is worthy of the people's trust. It should not be the people's burden to prove a public servant is NOT worthy. For how in all that is intelligible and doable under the sun can anyone prove a negative?
The assumption that "a man is innocent until proven guilty" is necessary in a criminal court. However, in an impeachment case (where what is at stake is the people's sacred trust and not an individual's right to life, liberty or property) adhesion to this tenet is a perversion of justice. The impeached has no human rights here to protect. But the Filipino nation has the very Foundation of its Laws and Democratic Institutions to protect.
Just because the victims of the impeached's "betrayal of public trust" are a faceless mob, does not make this a victimless crime. An impeached occupying an exalted office should resign even if his "betrayal of public trust" is merely alleged but not proven. But the framers of the Constitution (in their infinite wisdom) also chose to grant the impeached a trial before the Senate as his right to due process (which I believe is more than a public servant suspected of betraying a sacred trust deserves.)
In short, the impeachment process as defined by the Philippine Constitution can only be viewed as a gift to the Chief Justice and other high ranking public servants. Public servants of lesser rank, where suspicion alone is grounds for dismissal, are not so lucky.
I hope this helps the Senator-judges properly weigh the cost to the impeached should they convict him against the greater cost to their constituents should they acquit him. They should ask themselves before they cast their votes what between the two choices will require courage on their part and make the courageous choice.

1 Responses (Leave a Comment):
This my comment to a politician who asked if CJ Corona is being supported by a group that votes as one block. -
They are entitled to their own opinion Madame but they are not necessarily correct. One thing is almost for sure, that no politician will cross their ways for fear that they will not be voted upon by the group. Very unfortunate because this group in the past voted for some candidates first and foremost because they are winning and usually they are the rich candidates, and most often regardless of their questionable moral standing and even anemic performance as government officials. So sad! Hope that this can be addressed in the future for the sake of the common good.
Post a Comment