Wednesday, November 9, 2011

WHAT AN ENRICHING EXCHANGE OF COMMENTS AND NOTES OF EXPERIENCE AMONG MY FRIENDS REGARDING WELFARE LIKE CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFER PROGRAM IN THE PHILIPPINES!


When the government gives cash assistance to the poor through the Conditional Cash Transfer Program, it is not teachingf them mendicancy!
Like · · Share · 7 minutes ago
Reynaldo Quijada reyquijada.blogspot.com
 ·  ·  · 18 hours ago
    • Renato Flores That is your valued opinion Sir, but I have to strongly disagree. What matters are yoiur reason and what are they Sir.
      17 hours ago ·  ·  1
    • Marlene Damolo Howe Cash Transfer Program is only a bandaid that provides temporary relief. The government needs to provide education and livelihood programs that will help the people to be self sufficient. Like the old proverb says, Give the man a fish and he'll eat for a day. But teach the man how to fish and he'll eat for life!
      10 hours ago ·  ·  5
    • Maria G. Allawen Another form of corruption. How much does the poor really get and how much is unaccounted for?
      10 hours ago ·  ·  4
    • Mac McCarty On the condition that a family gets medical care for mothers (and mothers to be) and kids and keep their kids in school, they can collect CCTs for *5-years only*...so they stay kinda healthy and get at least a minimum education while they're learning to fish! Dumb & hungry gets nobody out of poverty.
      7 hours ago ·  ·  5
    • Mac McCarty Everything can be (and often is) subject to corruption...shall we just stop trying?
      7 hours ago ·  ·  1
    • Pedro Jacobo Its tried and tested that UN does it too. Indeed Macwe can't stop trying just because of the risk of corruption. Let us not confuse CCT with patronage politics that promotes mendicancy among the poor.
      6 hours ago ·  ·  3
    • Reynaldo Quijada Thank you for the feedback Friends.
      6 hours ago · 
    • Marlene Damolo Howe Social welfare is needed especially those who really need it! But also we need to find a balance so we don't ecnourage them to stay in poverty and not try to get out of poverty because the government gives them a hand out. Oftentimes, social programs are used and abused! Here in the US as a matter of fact I have seen so many people who abused the program while people like me worked hard and pay taxes to support them. I have never seen so many young able bodied people who came to the bank where I worked and cashed welfare checks and social security disability checks and reeked of alcohol. Few women even bragged to me about getting more money soon because they are pregnant again by another man and that will increase their welfare check as soon as the baby is born. That's why we need to reform our entitlement programs to encourage people to work hard and get out of poverty. Instead of monthly check, education and self-improvement is needed. There should be a limit as to how long they have to receive a hand out so they won't be expecting it and feel it's their right to receive them while people who worked and pay taxes will have to pay for them.
      5 hours ago ·  ·  1
    • Pedro Jacobo The limit is 5 years according to Mac......
      5 hours ago ·  ·  1
    • Mac McCarty Yes, 5 years. I too am familiar with welfare abuse in the US—I taught for years at a technical school that was certified for rehabilitation training and saw all kinds. However, when the school closed (because the owner was lost at sea in a boating accident) I was only able to collect unemployment for a few weeks and was then left on my own. Welfare, in the US, is positively dominated by professionals! (Or was back in the day.) Those kinds of problems hardly exist here—instead, we have our own brand of problems, like getting the people who are supposed to distribute the money to actually give it to the needy instead of to relatives or “ghosts.”

      Likewise, the *amount* of money available hardly meets the level of true needs. Fortunately, the vast majority of the crushingly poor here really have ambitions to work and fight their way out of constant poverty and need—and can use all the help they can get. Many struggle just to feed their children daily. Check this out, for instance:

      http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/insights/11/09/11/food-and-jobs-and-constant-hunger
      4 hours ago ·  ·  2
    • Marlene Damolo Howe Thank you Mac for sharing the link! I feel for those who are in need that's why I am constantly running on empty to give to my charities in the Philippines because my conscience just cannot take it that I am living comfortably here while my family and some people in the charities I support are destitute. It's true that there are abusers but in the Philippines, I think a large amount of the funds went to ghost projects, ghost employees and ghost welfare recipients.This is another area that we have to change in our government. We need to have a good accounting for all the funds given to a certain department. Corruption is easy for those unscrupulous people because we don't have good accounting of every peso spent. The president has a Herculean task in his hands to curb corruption.
      4 hours ago ·  ·  4
    • Yuko Takei ‎"Give the man a fish and he'll eat for a day. But teach the man how to fish and he'll eat for life!" It's an old Japanese/Chinese proverb I first heard from my father-in-law. That's why you don't see a lot many people here begging for money. Mendicancy in fact takes away from one a lot of his dignity, and worse, shame and decency!
      4 hours ago ·  ·  1
  • What an enriching exchange of ideas among you my dear friends! May I copy all your comments and your notes of experience and post it at my blog reyquijada.blogspot.com for many to see especially those in governemnt! Indeed, charity and education of the beneficiaries should go hand in hand! GOD BLESS ALL OF YOU!

0 Responses: